A weblog by Tom Coates concerning future media, social software and the web of data
Quote of the month: "This is not a brothel, there are no prostitutes here"
You can subscribe to an RSS feed, read the disclaimer or explore the archives

Links for 2007-01-23

Posted January 23, 2007 12:17 AM.

Comments

Please stay on-topic, informative and polite. I reserve the right to remove comments for whatever vague capricious reasons seem reasonable at the time.

I haven't checked this site in way too long, and come back to find I've been missing a mountain of good stuff.

I wanted to comment on the God Delusion kerfuffle that's going on. People are missing the point, including The Big Man, Dawkins himself.

It is futile to argue about beliefs. And it's even more futile to tell people what to believe. Dawkins is trying to make his well-deserved authority as a scientist -- science deals with the *physical* world -- turn him into an authority on other people's inner lives. That's something nobody except the person involved can know anything about. Dawkins is committing the same fallacy as someone who thinks religion holds the key to curing Aids. Science will eventually cure Aids; religion (in the sense of ethics) can tell us how to distribute the cure. Neither type of knowledge is any use in the other's territory.

Dawkins is applying rules valid in one type of knowledge to a completely different kind, and that always leads to BS. It's the same thought process a creationist uses, and Dawkins should know better.

The really sad thing, to me, is that the real point he's making, which is that people's beliefs can lead to terrible harm, is entirely right. That's true. I wish he'd made that message loud and clear, instead of getting sandbagged in a yes-no argument about the validity of someone's beliefs. It's not about the belief. It's about the harm.

Posted by: quixote at January 23, 2007 7:26 PM

Want to add your opinion?

© 1999-2007 Tom Coates